Guides › The Call of the Wild › Unit 6 · Big Ideas
Springboards: Nature, Nurture, and Dogs
Darwin, Rousseau, the science of the human–dog bond, and the question of what is 'natural.'
Suggested pacing: 3–4 days
- Natural selection and 'survival of the fittest'
- Nature vs. nurture
- How dogs were domesticated
- Learned helplessness and conditioning
- Rousseau and the 'noble savage' idea
Key terms
Science: Darwin
Darwin's On the Origin of Species (1859) proposed natural selection: organisms with helpful traits survive and reproduce. The phrase 'survival of the fittest' came from Herbert Spencer. In biology, 'fittest' means best suited to an environment, not strongest.
- Natural selection
- 'Fittest' = best adapted
- Buck adapts to a new environment
Psychology: conditioning
The man in the red sweater uses punishment to shape behavior, like operant conditioning. Psychologists warn that harsh punishment teaches fear, not understanding. Modern dog training relies on rewards. Buck also learns by watching other dogs: observational learning.
- Operant conditioning
- Punishment vs. reinforcement
- Observational learning
Science: the human–dog bond
Dogs descend from ancient wolves and were domesticated tens of thousands of years ago. Research shows dogs read human gestures and that gazing between dogs and owners raises oxytocin, a bonding hormone, in both.
- Domestication from wolves
- Dogs read human cues
- Oxytocin and bonding
Philosophy: civilization vs. nature
Jean-Jacques Rousseau argued that civilization corrupts natural goodness. Thomas Hobbes argued that life without society is a war of all against all. Buck's world contains both: brutal laws and pure love.
- Rousseau: nature is good
- Hobbes: nature is brutal
- Where does Buck's story land?
Discuss
- Is Buck's change nature or nurture?
- Does civilization make us better or worse?
- What does your pet understand about you?