Ate Your Homework

Guides › Lord of the Flies › Unit 7 · Extend

Unit 7 · Extend

Paired Texts & Writing

Philosophy, poetry, and nonfiction that answer Golding, plus essay prompts and a debate.

Suggested pacing: 1 week

Summary sheet: know this cold
  • Read Hobbes's chapter on the state of nature
  • Read an account of the 'Ata castaways
  • Pair with 'The Second Coming' by Yeats
  • Write a synthesis argument
  • Hold a structured debate

Key terms

Synthesis essayAn essay combining several sources
Debate resolutionThe statement teams argue for or against
ConstitutionFounding rules of a government
ExcerptA short passage from a longer work
CounterevidenceFacts that challenge a claim
Center cannot holdYeats's image of collapsing order

Philosophy

Hobbes's Leviathan, Chapter XIII, describes the state of nature; it is free on Project Gutenberg. Pair it with a short excerpt from Rousseau's Discourse on Inequality.

  • Hobbes, Leviathan, Ch. XIII
  • Rousseau, Discourse on Inequality (excerpt)
  • Compare to the island

Poetry and nonfiction

W. B. Yeats's 'The Second Coming' (1919), with its image that things fall apart and the center cannot hold, captures the collapse of order. Bregman's account of the 'Ata castaways offers a hopeful counter-story.

  • Yeats, 'The Second Coming' (1919)
  • Bregman, Humankind (2020), the 'Ata chapter
  • News accounts of the 1965 rescue

Essay prompts

Choose one; use the novel and one paired text.

  • Does the novel prove that people are naturally evil?
  • Which symbol best tracks the collapse of order?
  • Compare Golding's boys with the 'Ata castaways.
  • Why does the novel end with an adult at war?

Projects

Hold a formal debate; write a rules charter for the island that might have worked; or write a newspaper account of the rescue from the officer's view.

  • Structured debate
  • Island constitution
  • Officer's report

Discuss

  1. Write one rule that might have saved the island.
  2. Which paired text argues best against Golding?
  3. Who won your class debate, and why?

Read more