Ate Your Homework

Guides › Lord of the Flies › Unit 6 · Big Ideas

Unit 6 · Big Ideas

Springboards: Hobbes, Rousseau, and the Real Castaways

The philosophical debate over human nature, contested psychology experiments, and a real 1965 shipwreck that challenges the novel.

Suggested pacing: 4–5 days

Summary sheet: know this cold
  • Hobbes: life without government is 'nasty, brutish, and short'
  • Rousseau: civilization corrupts
  • Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment and its critics
  • Sherif's Robbers Cave study
  • The real Tongan castaways of 1965

Key terms

State of natureLife without government
LeviathanHobbes's 1651 book on government
Social contractAgreement to form a government
Stanford Prison ExperimentZimbardo's 1971 study, now heavily criticized
'Ata castawaysSix Tongan boys shipwrecked in 1965 who cooperated
ReplicationRepeating a study to test its findings

Philosophy: Hobbes vs. Rousseau

Thomas Hobbes argued in Leviathan (1651) that without a government, life would be a war of all against all. Jean-Jacques Rousseau argued that people are naturally good and that society corrupts them. Golding seems to side with Hobbes. Which philosopher would Piggy follow? Jack?

  • Hobbes: we need a strong ruler
  • Rousseau: nature is good, society corrupts
  • Locke: a middle path with natural rights

Psychology: experiments and their critics

Philip Zimbardo's 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment seemed to show that ordinary students quickly became cruel guards. Later researchers found that guards were coached and that the study had serious flaws, so it is now treated cautiously. Sherif's Robbers Cave (1954) showed boys forming hostile groups, and also how shared goals ended the hostility.

  • Stanford Prison Experiment (1971) and its critiques
  • Robbers Cave (1954)
  • Science changes as evidence is re-examined

History: the real Lord of the Flies

In 1965, six Tongan schoolboys ran away in a boat and were shipwrecked on the uninhabited island of 'Ata. They survived for about 15 months by cooperating: a garden, a work rota, a rule for settling quarrels, and music. Author Rutger Bregman retold the story in his book Humankind (2020) as evidence that people are more cooperative than Golding imagined.

  • Six Tongan boys, 1965
  • Cooperation, rules, and care
  • Rescued after about 15 months
  • Bregman, Humankind (2020)

Debate

Both the novel and the real story are evidence of something. Students can stage a formal debate: Resolved, that people are naturally cooperative.

  • Use philosophy, psychology, and history
  • Evaluate evidence quality
  • Fiction vs. fact

Discuss

  1. Hobbes or Rousseau: who's right?
  2. Why did the real castaways succeed where Golding's boys failed?
  3. Can fiction be evidence about human nature?

Read more