Ate Your Homework

Guides › The Giver › Unit 7 · Extend

Unit 7 · Extend

Paired Texts & Writing

Stories, poems, and essays that ask the same questions, plus essay prompts and projects.

Suggested pacing: 1 week

Summary sheet: know this cold
  • Compare The Giver with 'The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas'
  • Compare with 'Harrison Bergeron'
  • Read Plato's cave as a paired text
  • Write an argument about the ending
  • Design and critique a utopia

Key terms

Paired textA second text read alongside the main one
OmelasLe Guin's happy city built on one child's suffering
Harrison BergeronVonnegut's story of forced equality
Socratic seminarStudent-led discussion built on questions
CounterargumentAn opposing view an essay addresses
RebuttalA response to the counterargument

Short stories

Ursula K. Le Guin's 'The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas' (1973) imagines a joyful city whose happiness depends on one child's suffering, and the people who leave. Kurt Vonnegut's 'Harrison Bergeron' (1961) shows equality enforced by handicapping anyone above average. Both are in many school anthologies.

  • Le Guin, 'Omelas' (1973)
  • Vonnegut, 'Harrison Bergeron' (1961)
  • Compare: who 'walks away' in The Giver?

Philosophy and nonfiction

Plato's Allegory of the Cave (Republic, Book VII) is free on Project Gutenberg. Lowry's 1994 Newbery acceptance speech describes the memories that shaped the book.

  • Plato, Republic, Book VII
  • Lowry's Newbery acceptance speech
  • Articles on memory science

Essay prompts

Choose one and support it with evidence from the novel and one paired text.

  • Is the community's trade-off ever justified?
  • What does the ending mean?
  • How does language control people in The Giver?
  • Compare Jonas to the ones who walk away from Omelas.

Projects

Design a utopia with three rules, then trade with a partner who must find its hidden cost. Or write the first chapter of what happens in the community after Jonas leaves.

  • Utopia design-and-critique
  • Sequel chapter
  • Socratic seminar on freedom vs. safety

Discuss

  1. Would you walk away from Omelas?
  2. Which paired text sharpened your view of the community?
  3. Design a 'perfect' rule. What is its cost?

Read more