Guides › The Giver › Unit 6 · Big Ideas
Springboards: Happiness, Freedom, Memory
The philosophy of the good life and the psychology of memory and emotion, through the lens of Jonas's world.
Suggested pacing: 3–4 days
- Plato's cave and seeing the truth
- Utilitarianism and its critics
- Nozick's 'experience machine'
- How memory works and why we forget
- Why negative emotions are useful
Key terms
Philosophy: the cave
In Plato's Republic (Book VII), prisoners chained in a cave see only shadows and think they are reality. One escapes, sees the sun, and returns to tell the others, who don't believe him. Jonas is the escaped prisoner. The full text is free online.
- Shadows vs. reality
- Enlightenment is painful
- The returning prisoner is rejected
Philosophy: happiness vs. freedom
Utilitarianism says the right act produces the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Critics answer that some things, like freedom, can't be traded away. Philosopher Robert Nozick's 'experience machine' asks: would you plug into a machine that gave you perfect pleasant experiences forever? Most people say no, suggesting we value reality, not just feeling good.
- Greatest happiness for the greatest number
- Rights that shouldn't be traded
- Nozick's experience machine (1974)
Psychology: memory and emotion
Psychologists distinguish episodic memory (personal events) from semantic memory (facts). Emotional events are remembered more strongly. Negative emotions such as fear and sadness are useful signals; people who can't feel pain often get badly hurt.
- Episodic vs. semantic memory
- Emotion strengthens memory
- Pain as protection
- Collective memory: how societies remember
History connection
Real governments have tried to erase memories of the past by rewriting textbooks or destroying records. Historians and museums work to preserve collective memory so societies can learn from it.
- Censorship of history
- Museums and memorials
- Why we study painful history
Discuss
- Would you plug into the experience machine?
- Is the community a utilitarian society?
- Why should we remember painful history?